Who's the man from the 9 dimensions?

SCIENCE COMMENTARY

Hirosi Ooguri (Scientific Advisor)

On January 20, 2016, Prof. Ooguri Hirosi gave a lecture entitled “Who's the man from the 9 dimensions?” at Miraikan as a part of the premier event of the movie. The following is an excerpt of the lecture, in which he explained the scientific background of the movie.

INTRODUCTION

“The movie ‘The Man from the 9 Dimensions’ was born from our desire to explain physics to the general public and what physicists are striving to discover. One of the missions of physics is to discover the fundamental laws of the natural world and to use them to address such profound questions as how our beautiful Universe began. We wanted to use this movie to show how scientists are pursuing this goal.”

photo: Chieko Kobayashi
From Philosophy/Religion to Scientific Method

“Since the dawn of history, humans have continually being asking such questions as ‘How did the Universe begin?’, ‘What is the Universe made of?’, and ‘What is our place in this Universe?’ Philosophies and religions that have emerged over the millennia can all trace their origins to these questions. However, 400 years ago, we began to approach these questions from an entirely different angle: the scientific method. It started with Galileo Galilei pointing his telescope toward the night sky and opening up a whole new window onto the Universe, enabling us to use the scientific method to unravel the mysteries of the cosmos. This triggered what has been called the ‘Scientific Revolution.’ Over the 400 years since then, we have made tremendous progress toward understanding the Universe.”

Tracing the History of Our Efforts to Understand the Cosmos from a Macroscopic Perspective

“Current research suggests that the Universe came into being 13.8 billion years ago in a high-temperature, highly dense state. This was what we call the ‘Big Bang.’ The General Theory of Relativity that Einstein discovered in 1915 made it possible to study the birth and the evolution of the Universe in a scientific fashion. There are three pieces of evidence for the Big Bang: Hubble’s discovery that the Universe has been expanding, the calculation of the ratio of hydrogen atoms to helium atoms created within three minutes of the beginning of the Universe, and the observation of light emitted 400,000 years later. The Big Bang was followed by a period called the ‘Dark Ages’ of the Universe; at the end of the Dark Ages, the first stars were born, structures were formed, the Galaxy came into being, and 9 billion years later, the sun and the Earth were formed creating our solar system. The first life was born on Earth 3.5 billion years later, gradually evolving into humankind over a very long period of time, and eventually reached the stage at which we began to ask ‘Why was the Universe formed?’ and ‘What is our place in it?’ The fact that the Universe had slowly developed over a period of 13.8 billion years is absolutely crucial to our birth as intelligent life. But why has the Universe lasted for such a long time? This is one of the biggest mysteries of the Universe. To understand it, we need to study the Universe's beginning.”

The Moment of the Universe's Birth from a Microscopic Perspective

“What would we see if we traced our way back to 0.0001 second after the birth of the Universe? Even the protons and neutrons were disintegrated into quarks, and the Universe was like a scorching hot soup with elementary particles flying around everywhere. We actually have a theory to describe such a soup; the so-called Standard Model summarizes our current understanding of the world of elementary particles. The theory has been verified over and over again by many experiments at the microscopic level. With that theory we can explain, in precise quantitative terms, what happened between 0.0001 to 0.00000000001 of a second after the birth of the Universe! That is to say, in the fraction of time in which there are 10 zeros after the decimal point. However, the Standard Model is not perfect. Current observations of the Universe suggest that matter that can be explained by the Standard Model account for just 5% of the Universe as a whole. Another 27% is thought to be dark matter, while the remaining share of almost 70% consists of a mysterious type of energy called dark energy. Thus, after working so hard to study the Universe over the last 400 years, we find ourselves knowing only about 5% of it. So, what was happening before the epoch of the Standard Model? To discover this, we will need a more fundamental theory; a theory that goes beyond the Standard Model.”

Theory of Everything ≈ Superstring Theory?

“One of the most promising hypotheses for the much earlier state of the Universe is the so-called cosmic inflation. To gain a precise, quantitative understanding of this inflationary stage of the Universe, we need a theory that unifies the law of gravity in the macroscopic world and the law of elementary particles in the microscopic world. The most promising is the superstring theory. In the superstring theory, the ultimate basic building blocks of matter are ‘strings’ rather than ‘point particles.’ This is still only a hypothesis and has yet to be proven experimentally. In the superstring theory, even the notion of dimensions of space also needs to be reconsidered. This movie explores a world in 9 dimensions predicted by the superstring theory. We humans experience space as 3 dimensions, so this means that there must be 6 extra dimensions. It is expected that these 6 extra-dimensions are curled into a compact “Calabi-Yau ” space that cannot be observed directly.
One of the challenges for us theoretical physicists is to derive quantitative predictions on elementary particles from the geometric structure of Calabi-Yau spaces. Calabi-Yau space is highly complex and its structure is still not well understood, even by mathematicians. Solving this is one of my research agenda, but I am afraid that we will have to leave its discussion for another time.”

Conclusion

“The film ‘The Man from the 9 Dimensions’ depicts the physicists who are trying to discover the ultimate unified theory that combines the laws of the macroscopic world, namely the theory of gravity to try to understand the Universe, and the laws of the microscopic world, namely quantum mechanics and elementary particle theory. In the world of theoretical physics, the power of mathematics is very important. I want to combine the power of mathematics with results of experiments and observations to solve the mysteries of the Universe. Although we have not yet understood what he, T.o.E. is, I want to get as close to him as I can in my own limited life. I hope that the next generation will pick up the search where I leave off.”

Glossary

Theory of Everything
The ultimate unified theory to explain all the physical phenomena in the natural world, from this Earth on which we live, to the farthest reaches of the Universe, with a single law. Currently, we know two sets of laws that describe our world. One is “quantum mechanics,” which explains the microscopic world, and the other is the “general theory of relativity, ” which is the law of gravity that explains the macroscopic world. If we go back to the moment when the Universe was born, we find that it was unimaginably small, hot and dense. Without a “Theory of Everything, ” it is impossible to understand that moment of the Universe's birth free of contradictions. Discovery of the “Theory of Everything,” would tremendously advance our understanding of the Universe. It would dramatically change our views on the Universe and the world and may also have a broader impact on science and technology. The name of the mysterious man appearing in this film is “T.o.E.,” which is the acronym for “Theory of Everything”.
Superstring Theory
The superstring theory is the leading candidate for the Theory of Everything. According to the superstring theory, the fundamental constituent of the world that makes up everything is not the elementary particles, but strings of energy stretched out in one dimension. Unlike the Standard Model of Elementary Particle, which has 17 types of elementary particles, the superstring theory describes everything in terms of a single type of string, and the differences in the vibration patterns of the string are believed to correspond to the various types of elementary particles. However, in order for the strings to exist, the three spatial dimensions that we are familiar with are not sufficient; instead, nine spatial dimensions are necessary. The remaining six dimensions make the so-called “Calabi-Yau space.” As the mathematics and geometry that explain the Calabi-Yau space have yet to be completed, we still do not know what form this space takes. To assess if the superstring theory is accurate, it is necessary to provide experimental proof of the presence of the “extra dimensions” (the remaining six dimensions).
Elementary Particles
Elementary particles are the smallest units that make up substances. Since time immemorial, the question of “what is everything made of? ” has intrigued the human mind. Around the 4th century BC, Democritus, a Greek philosopher, postulated that everything is made of atoms, small particles that cannot be split up into any smaller particles. Today, 2,500 years after Democritus, we know that the microscopic world can be described by 17 types of elementary particles with different properties and different roles. This film takes up the challenge of offering a visual presentation of various elementary particles such as the Higgs boson, whose discovery led to the 2013 Nobel Prize in Physics to two theorists who predicted it, the light-transmitting photon that is closely linked to our everyday lives, and the neutrino, whose curiously property called “neutrino oscillation” led to the 2015 Nobel Prize in Physics.
Standard Model
This is the theory that summarizes the laws that we currently know about in the world of elementary particles. The Standard Model is able to explain the types of elementary particles and their interaction with one another, but there are still several unresolved problems. While it is currently considered that there are 17 types of elementary particles, how many types are there in total? How were the properties of the elementary particles determined? Furthermore, the Standard Model does not contain dark matter and is unable to explain gravity. Hence, the Standard Model still cannot be a completed theory, and the search for a theory that can explain everything in the Universe continues even today.
Particle Accelerator
A particle accelerator is a machine that accelerates particles such as protons close to the speed of light, and then makes them collide with each other under high-energy conditions. Analyzing the data of the particles generated through such collisions can bring about the discovery of new particles, which contributes to the study of physics. This film provides a visual presentation of the trajectory taken by elementary particles as they are scattered, in the instant when the Higgs boson is created through a collision between protons. This is based on collision data provided by the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN), the world's largest research laboratory for elementary particle physics, which is renowned for the first observation of the Higgs boson particle in 2012. The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) accelerator built by CERN, spanning the border between France and the suburbs of Geneva, Switzerland, is a massive machine with a circumference of about 27km.
Calabi-Yau Space
The Calabi-Yau Space refers to the six extra dimensions that are predicted by the superstring theory. The Calabi-Yau Space is folded very compactly, and can neither be seen or felt by us. This is why we only observe our three-dimensional world. In the superstring theory, the string vibrates according to the shape of the Calabi-Yau Space, and the differences in the vibration patterns are thought to correspond to the 17 types of elementary particles. The film gives a visual representation of the six extra dimensions of the Calabi-Yau space as if it is seen from our three dimensions, by using precise mathematical formulas for the space.

Who's the man from the 9 dimensions?

Hirosi Ooguri (Scientific Advisor)

menu